Responses of Bottlenose Dolphins to Construction and Demolition of Underwater Structures

Open Access Report 2006

Mote Marine Laboratory

Of all of the anthropogenic noise sources in the marine environment, construction and demolition noise and their effects have received perhaps the least attention, and yet they are commonplace activities in many offshore and coastal waters. In the Gulf of Mexico, for example, thousands of oil production platforms have been constructed since the mid 1900′ s, and more than 100 of the older rigs are being removed each year (Klima et aI. , 1988). Coastal development involves the construction of bridges, causeways, piers, and other structures at the water’s edge. Further development leads to the replacement of existing structures and removal of these older structures. These activities occur within the ranges of a variety of marine mammals, but little work has been done to evaluate their impacts on the animals. Though the precautionary principle would dictate otherwise, marine mammals are given little regulatory protection from potential adverse impacts from construction/demolition activities. There are currently no provisions under the federal Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 requiring review and permitting of coastal construction or demolition projects. Evidence indicates that construction and similar activities, such as drilling, impact marine mammals in several ways. Early work with bowhead whales (Balaena mysticetus) indicates that they avoid areas of heavy industrial activity. Richardson et aI. (1985) examined distribution patterns of whales exposed to oil and gas exploration and production in the Beaufort Sea relative to historical records, and noted shifts in habitat usage. In another study, bowhead whales were distributed farther from a drilling rig than they would be under a random scenario (Schick and Urban 2000). At a construction site in waters off western Hong Kong, groups of Indo-Pacific humpback dolphins (Sousa chinensis) doubled their swim speed during periods of active pile driving, however, abundance estimates did not change significantly (Wiirsig et aI. 2000). Todd et al. (1996) examined the distribution, resighting rate, and residency of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) in Newfoundland waters before, during, and after exposure to underwater explosions and did not notice marked behavioral reactions to the detonations. Importantly though, the rate of entrapment in acoustically enhanced fishing nets increased at the onset of underwater drilling activity and sequences of explosions, suggesting a decline in orientation ability. Finneran et al. (2000) measured the auditory and behavioral responses of two dolphins and a beluga whale to simulated underwater explosions. None of the animals showed threshold shifts to even the loudest stimulus (500 kg explosive at 1.7 km range), but all showed behavioral responses during the experiment (Finneran et al. 2000). In Sarasota Bay, Florida, the construction of a large fixed-span bridge and subsequent demolition of the existing drawbridge allowed us the opportunity to investigate the potential effects of marine building on coastal bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus). In the absence of data clearly indicating no jeopardy, or data clearly showing effects to distance from the activity, it is important for biologists and regulatory agencies to develop a better understanding of the potential adverse effects of such wide-scale activities on these animals. One approach would be to follow the model of Richardson et al. (1985), taking advantage of opportunistic “experiments” to examine the distribution and behavior of dolphins before, during, and after construction or demolition activities. Extensive long-term databases exist that can quantitatively define dolphins’ patterns of habitat usage in Sarasota Bay before construction (Scott et al. 1990; Wells 1991, 2003), and can be used for comparisons with similar data collected during and after demolition. Photographic identification surveys for dolphins have been conducted for two weeks each month through these waters for the last decade. We continued these surveys and intensified data collection efforts relative to the bridge project schedule, and related behavior and distribution patterns to the noise generated by the construction and demolition activities. Research Objectives To develop a better understanding of the potential effects of bridge construction and demolition on bottlenose dolphins, in order to aid regulatory agencies in protecting these animals by: 1) documenting distributions of dolphins relative to an area of marine construction or demolition and comparing distributions to historical distributions; 2) describing sound levels of construction/demolition; 3) during the acute (explosive) phase, relating dolphin behavior to the explosion and associated sound levels at the animals.

Link To Publication

Similar Research

Damped cylindrical spreading model: Estimation of mitigated pile driving noise levels

Open Access Research Article 2021

Applied Acoustics

Extending the Damped cylindrical spreading model to the case of mitigated pile driving noise, using corresponding measurement data from five offshore sites in the North Sea....
Read More

Noise pollution causes parental stress on marine invertebrates, the Giant scallop example

Open Access Research Article 2024

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Investigation on cross generational effects of underwater noise, using pile driving noise. Adults exposed to increasing levels during gametogenesis. Offspring also exposed. Noise reduced reproductive investment...
Read More

Pile driving noise impacts behavioral patterns of important East Asian juvenile marine fishes

Open Access Research Article 2024

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Assessment of pile driving noise impact on 3 sensitive species local to Korea. Pile driving noise playback induced rapid changes in L. japonicus and A. schlegelii...
Read More

Underwater noise characterization of down-the-hole pile driving activities off Biorka Island, Alaska

Open Access Research Article 2020

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Characterization of DTH piling. Noise levels from single strike were lower than impact pile driving, cumulative sound exposure levels are comparable due to higher strike rate....
Read More

Scaling laws for unmitigated pile driving: Dependence of underwater noise on strike energy, pile diameter, ram weight, and water depth,

Open Access Research Article 2022

Applied Acoustics

Examination of possibilities and limits of estimating approximate source or any other levels(of underwater piling) by scaling laws, using measurement data from previous projects. It is...
Read More
Keywords: Piling, Scaling laws

Review of PAM studies in the Coastal Waters West of Taiwan during 2013–2022

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2023

Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

Passive acoustic monitoring widely used in Taiwan noise and biodiversity monitoring. Paper reviews PAM studies encompassing pre-construction, construction, and operational phases of the first offshore wind...
Read More

Comprehensive analysis of the seismic wave fields generated by offshore pile driving: A case study at the BARD Offshore 1 offshore wind farm

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2024

Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

Piling induces ground vibrations and particle motion with potential to affect marine life. Seismic wave field interface is thought to be the cause of this. Paper...
Read More

Review on Existing Data on Underwater Sounds from Pile Driving Activities

Open Access Project Report 2020

Seiche Ltd.

Review of published acoustic data from pile driving activity. Majority come from wind farm operations. Very little public data available from Oil & Gas sector....
Read More

A sampling, exposure and receptor framework for identifying factors that modulate behavioural responses to disturbance in cetaceans

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2022

Journal of Animal Ecology

Assessment of behavioural response studies conducted on cetaceans in response to anthropogenic noise. 43 modulating factors identified in effectiveness of BRS. Research indicates that factors relating...
Read More

Scaling offshore pile driving noise: examples for scenarios with and without a big bubble curtain

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2022

Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics

Assessment of sound level predictions in relation to of mitigation measures for offshore piling to comply with pressure thresholds. Complex numerical models often applied for precise...
Read More