Effect of pile-driving playback sound level on fish-catching efficiency in harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena)

Pay-walled Article 2019

Aquatic Mammals

The foundations of offshore wind turbine parks are often constructed by means of percussion pile driving. Broadband impulsive sounds generated by pile driving may disturb and distract marine mammals such as harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena); their concentration may be reduced, affecting the skills they need for foraging (e.g., timing and precision) or reducing their ability to catch prey and, thus, their foraging efficiency. The resulting reduction in fitness may eventually lead to population declines. Therefore, it is important to understand the effects of these anthropogenic sounds on the ability of harbor porpoises to catch fish. Two captive harbor porpoises (porpoise F05 and porpoise M06) performed a fish-catching task (i.e., retrieving dead fish from a net feeding cage) while they were exposed to low ambient noise (quiet conditions) and impulsive pile-driving playback sounds at three (porpoise M06) or four (porpoise F05) mean received single-strike sound exposure levels (SELss) between 125 and 143 dB re 1 µPa2s. The two study animals differed in their fish-catching success rate at all noise levels, including under quiet conditions: Porpoise F05 was less likely to catch fish than porpoise M06. They also responded differently to increasing SELss: Only porpoise F05 was significantly more likely to terminate trials and less likely to catch fish as SELss increased above 134 dB, but her trial failure rate remained unaffected by increasing SELss. The time taken to catch a fish did not vary with SELss but was slightly longer for porpoise F05 than for porpoise M06. Results suggest that high-amplitude pile driving sounds are likely to negatively affect foraging in some harbor porpoises by decreasing their catch success rate and increasing the termination rate of their fish-catching attempts; the severity of the effects is likely to increase with increasing pile driving SELss. However, individual differences in responses to sound, termination rates, and fish-catching success (even in ambient conditions) may complicate the quantification of the impacts of pile driving sounds on harbor porpoises.

Link To Publication

Similar Research

Damped cylindrical spreading model: Estimation of mitigated pile driving noise levels

Open Access Research Article 2021

Applied Acoustics

Extending the Damped cylindrical spreading model to the case of mitigated pile driving noise, using corresponding measurement data from five offshore sites in the North Sea....
Read More

Noise pollution causes parental stress on marine invertebrates, the Giant scallop example

Open Access Research Article 2024

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Investigation on cross generational effects of underwater noise, using pile driving noise. Adults exposed to increasing levels during gametogenesis. Offspring also exposed. Noise reduced reproductive investment...
Read More

Pile driving noise impacts behavioral patterns of important East Asian juvenile marine fishes

Open Access Research Article 2024

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Assessment of pile driving noise impact on 3 sensitive species local to Korea. Pile driving noise playback induced rapid changes in L. japonicus and A. schlegelii...
Read More

Underwater noise characterization of down-the-hole pile driving activities off Biorka Island, Alaska

Open Access Research Article 2020

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Characterization of DTH piling. Noise levels from single strike were lower than impact pile driving, cumulative sound exposure levels are comparable due to higher strike rate....
Read More

Scaling laws for unmitigated pile driving: Dependence of underwater noise on strike energy, pile diameter, ram weight, and water depth,

Open Access Research Article 2022

Applied Acoustics

Examination of possibilities and limits of estimating approximate source or any other levels(of underwater piling) by scaling laws, using measurement data from previous projects. It is...
Read More
Keywords: Piling, Scaling laws

Review of PAM studies in the Coastal Waters West of Taiwan during 2013–2022

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2023

Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

Passive acoustic monitoring widely used in Taiwan noise and biodiversity monitoring. Paper reviews PAM studies encompassing pre-construction, construction, and operational phases of the first offshore wind...
Read More

Comprehensive analysis of the seismic wave fields generated by offshore pile driving: A case study at the BARD Offshore 1 offshore wind farm

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2024

Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

Piling induces ground vibrations and particle motion with potential to affect marine life. Seismic wave field interface is thought to be the cause of this. Paper...
Read More

Review on Existing Data on Underwater Sounds from Pile Driving Activities

Open Access Project Report 2020

Seiche Ltd.

Review of published acoustic data from pile driving activity. Majority come from wind farm operations. Very little public data available from Oil & Gas sector....
Read More

A sampling, exposure and receptor framework for identifying factors that modulate behavioural responses to disturbance in cetaceans

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2022

Journal of Animal Ecology

Assessment of behavioural response studies conducted on cetaceans in response to anthropogenic noise. 43 modulating factors identified in effectiveness of BRS. Research indicates that factors relating...
Read More

Scaling offshore pile driving noise: examples for scenarios with and without a big bubble curtain

Open Access Peer Reviewed Research Article 2022

Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics

Assessment of sound level predictions in relation to of mitigation measures for offshore piling to comply with pressure thresholds. Complex numerical models often applied for precise...
Read More